Eh... I'm not sure. I think the issue is how he handled the "vitriol" by attacking people.
And it did start out with people saying "We don't reccomend it but you can check here", but LBTT took it as an attack on his intelligence. This is a different attitude from the usual user that joins and it didn't leave a good taste in anyone's mouth. So yes, you're right that this thread could look bad to any noobs that are joining, but I do feel that the things that were said were warranted.
Also, if anyone is serious about a WASP redesign I know a guy who's working on one as well. Feel free to contact him
here.